Reilly Craft Pizza & Drink is a modern Italian restaurant in a restored historic building at 101 E Pennington St, Downtown Tucson. The menu features wood-fired pizzas like Arugula & Prosciutto, house-made pastas, eight $14 craft cocktails, and local draft beer. Dining options include the main room, rooftop, beer garden, and a private room for up to 14 guests.
Reilly Craft Pizza & Drink has become one of Downtown Tucson’s most talked-about dining spots, and it’s easy to see why. The restaurant occupies a restored historic building once the Reilly Funeral Home reimagined with exposed ductwork, rough-hewn wood, and brick arches. Chef-owner Tyler Fenton, who reportedly tested more than 50 dough recipes before settling on Reilly’s long-fermented crust, built a menu around modern Italian cooking and craft cocktails.
What Food Does Reilly Craft Pizza & Drink Serve?
Reilly’s menu centers on wood-fired pizza, house-made pasta, and shareable starters. Standouts include the Arugula & Prosciutto pizza, Margherita, and Mafalda pasta, alongside salads, meatballs, and a tiramisu served in a jar.
Signature Pizzas
Reilly’s pizza dough is long-fermented and baked hot, producing a blistered, leopard-spotted crust.
| Pizza | Highlights |
| Arugula & Prosciutto | Fan-favorite; peppery greens, cured prosciutto, grana |
| Margherita | Tomato sauce, mozzarella, fresh basil a classic |
| Mafalda | Beef ragu pasta, not a pizza a hearty, saucy favorite |
| Vegan | Tomato sauce, mushroom, peppers, no dairy |
Beyond Pizza
- Starters: Housemade bread with cultured butter, smashed cucumbers with whipped ricotta, ricotta toast with calabrian chile honey
- Meatballs: Pork and dry-aged AZ beef meatballs in tomato sauce
- Salads: Apple, pecan brittle & gorgonzola; Caesar; Chopped
- Sides: Brussels sprouts with house hot sauce and pecan brittle crumbs; herb & garlic fries with grana and aioli
- Dessert: Tiramisu served in a jar a signature touch guests consistently mention
What Cocktails and Drinks Does Reilly Serve?
Reilly pours eight signature cocktails, each named after Tucson-area landmarks, priced at $14. Highlights include the Riverside Spritz, Encanto Espresso Martini, and Iron Horse Old Fashioned, plus a rotating Crew’s Whim and local draft beer.
| Cocktail | Key Ingredients | Price |
| Riverside Spritz | Vodka, aperitif, orange, sparkling wine | $14 |
| Encanto Espresso Martini | Vodka, cold brew, espresso liqueur, vanilla | $14 |
| Iron Horse Old Fashioned | Bourbon & malt whiskey, black pepper + cardamom syrup | $14 |
| Hedrick Acres Daisy | Tequila, chile, lime, agave | $14 |
| Crew’s Whim | Bartender’s monthly creation | Market price |
Beer drinkers can try Barrio Blonde Ale from Tucson’s own Barrio Brewing Co., alongside drafts from Arizona and California breweries. The wine list runs from $10 glasses to Italian bottles over $100.
What Is the Dining Atmosphere Like at Reilly Craft Pizza & Drink?
Reilly offers four distinct settings: an energetic main dining room inside a restored historic building, rooftop seating, a casual beer garden, and a private room for up to 14 guests. Dress code is casual throughout.
- Main Dining Room: Lively, loud at peak hours, with architectural character from the original building
- Rooftop: Elevated outdoor seating, open seating with counter ordering
- Beer Garden: Relaxed, casual, good for groups
- Private Room: Seats up to 14; larger parties and buyouts available in the Beer Garden
Diners on OpenTable describe the space as “lively” and “good for groups,” though several reviews note it can get noisy during busy evening service.
What Are Reilly Craft Pizza & Drink’s Hours?
Listed hours vary by source. OpenTable and the restaurant’s reservation system show Tuesday–Sunday, 5:00 PM–9:00 PM (closed Monday). MapQuest lists slightly different hours, including Friday–Saturday until 10:00 PM. Because online listings disagree, confirm current hours by calling (520) 882-5550 or checking reillypizza.com before you go.
| Source | Reported Hours |
| OpenTable | Tue–Sun, 5–9 PM (closed Monday) |
| MapQuest | Sun 5–9 PM, Tue–Thu 5–9 PM, Fri–Sat 5–10 PM, closed Monday |
Older press coverage from the restaurant’s opening period listed longer hours (11 AM–10 PM or later), but those no longer appear to reflect current operations.
What Do Reviews Say About Reilly Craft Pizza & Drink?
Reilly holds a 4.5-star rating on OpenTable from 1,437 reviews, and a separate Yelp listing shows roughly 870 reviews. Diners consistently praise the pizza, pasta, and service, while noise levels are the most common complaint.
Common themes from verified OpenTable reviews:
- Food: Fennel sausage pizza and rigatoni pasta frequently singled out as standouts
- Service: Staff like Nate and Avery earn repeat mentions for attentiveness
- Ambience: Described as “lively” and architecturally unique, but “too noisy” during peak hours
- Value: Rated 4.4/5 slightly lower than food and service scores
If you’re sensitive to noise, request an early reservation or ask about rooftop or beer garden seating.
How Should You Plan Your Visit to Reilly Craft Pizza & Drink?
Reservations are strongly recommended, especially on weekends. Parking is available along Pennington Street or in the nearby Pennington Street Garage, and the restaurant is easily reachable via Uber.
- Reservations: Strongly suggested; parties of 8–14 should call (520) 882-5550
- Large groups: Parties over 14, or private events, should use the Event Inquiry Form on reillypizza.com
- Parking: Street parking on Pennington Street, or the Pennington Street Garage nearby
- Rideshare: Uber and other delivery/rideshare services serve the address directly
- Stay informed: Join Reilly’s mailing list for special events and restaurant news
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Reilly Craft Pizza & Drink good for large groups?
Yes. Parties of 8–14 can call ahead, and the Beer Garden accommodates larger groups and full buyouts.
Does Reilly have outdoor seating?
Yes, Reilly offers both rooftop seating and a separate beer garden for outdoor dining.
How many reviews does Reilly have on OpenTable?
Reilly holds a 4.5-star rating from 1,437 verified OpenTable reviews.
How many reviews does Reilly have on Yelp?
Yelp and MapQuest listings show approximately 870 reviews.
Are the cocktails at Reilly all the same price?
Most signature cocktails are priced at $14, except the rotating Crew’s Whim, which is market price.
Does Reilly offer gluten-free options?
Yes, an 8-inch square “grandma style” gluten-free pizza crust is available.
Is Reilly kid-friendly?
Yes, families dine at Reilly, and quick options like fries make it workable for younger diners, though there’s no dedicated kids’ menu.
What is Reilly’s most popular pizza?
The Arugula & Prosciutto pizza is consistently named a top pick by diners and appears repeatedly in reviews.
Do I need a reservation at Reilly?
Reservations are strongly suggested; the restaurant itself notes walk-ins should expect to wait.
Where can I park near Reilly Craft Pizza & Drink?
Street parking is available on Pennington Street, with the Pennington Street Garage as a nearby alternative.
